Research notebook · checked 5 November 2026

Follow the reading record.

A famous name beside a book is a claim. Here is what stands behind ours.

How the shelf is built

Each work has at least two documented readers or people who engaged directly with its text. An autobiography can establish a reported reading. A published response establishes textual engagement. A signature establishes contact with a passage. A witness account is labelled as testimony.

These are different kinds of evidence. None automatically proves completion, agreement, or influence over later actions. The English editions for sale are practical reading copies, rather than the historical copies or translations.

Why these works

The selection puts contrasting readers beside the same work and favours evidence you can inspect. Its themes include power, moral choice, ambition, self-examination, and the cost of glory. Those are editorial reasons to explore the books, rather than a claim that reading them produces greatness.

The Republic

Julius Caesar

The Iliad

Civil Disobedience

The Outline of History

Uncle Tom’s Cabin

  • Malcolm X — Autobiographical reading self-report.
    The Autobiography of Malcolm X (1965)
    Chapter 11, “Saved”; paragraph on slavery and reading novels
  • Leo Tolstoy — Author’s own published appraisal.
    What Is Art?
    Chapter XVI, printed pp. 166–167

The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire

The Prince

The Divine Comedy

Bhagavad Gita

Parallel Lives

  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau — Autobiographical self-report.
    Confessions, Book I
    Childhood reading; discussion of Agesilaus, Brutus, and Aristides
  • Ralph Waldo Emerson — Published textual response.
    Essays: First Series (1841)
    “Heroism”; reproduced in this 1907 collection

Confessions

The New Testament

Claims we did not promote to the shelf

Hitler’s supposed favourite novels. Our Julius Caesar entry now attributes a reported stage-design sketch to Ryback. That is a separate claim from the popular novel lists, which often rely on edited Table Talk or book ownership. Those lists require further title-by-title checking. See Mikael Nilsson’s source-critical study, Vierteljahrshefte für Zeitgeschichte 67 (2019), pp. 105–145.

Napoleon and Plutarch. A later memoir by Bourrienne mentions Napoleon reading “Plutarch”, without securely identifying an edition or the Lives. We chose Rousseau’s and Emerson’s more specific records for that card.

Lincoln and Julius Caesar. Lincoln’s 17 August 1863 letter to James Hackett names several Shakespeare plays, but not Julius Caesar. It cannot support that particular pairing.

Corrections

Found a better primary source or a mistaken locator? Send the work, reader, and source reference to @blackrockofsaturn. A link to the evidence is more useful than another unsourced list.